Well, I'll weigh-in on this issue!
I go through my Creed-stages (as I call them), so, currently, my favorite video is What If because the guys are really rockin' out in it! (I've actually been watching the What If video on the 'net a lot lately! I know, I'm weird.) And my song obsession of the month has been What If.
However, I *really* like the One Last Breath video because Stapp looks super sexy in it (like he does in all the videos)!
Good thread to start!
...now, check back with me in a month, and you might get a different answer.