None of the reviews I posted were written by professionals. I never claimed that any of the reviews were written by professional music critics. They were written by some INXS fans who attended the shows and enjoyed Scott Stapp.
There seemed to be some question about how Scott would be received by INXS' fans. Most of the accounts I have read have been positive, some have been indifferent, very few have been negative.
I thought some people on this site, might be interested in reading some unbiased opinions about Scott's performance. These posters from other fansites have no reason to sing his praises or give him any unearned props. And, unlike some of the 'professional' reviewers, they don't have an axe to grind or an agenda to promote.